| First Place | |||
| Group | Name | Beer Name | |
| 1, 6 | Bob Barrett | Oberon Clone | |
| 2-5 | Alex Pettit | Maple Marzen | |
| 7, 15 | Jason Pruette | Ale-n-Dog Alt Blind | |
| 8, 11 | Alex Pettit | Clark Kent Mild | |
| 9, 19 | John Rathmell | Throne of Hades Barleywine | |
| 10 | David Liles | Copperhead Amber Ale | |
| 12, 13 | John Rathmell | Realm of Osmodius Imperial Stout | |
| 14 | Ken Celski | Kennybrew IPA | |
| 16, 17 | Brad Sancho | Belgian Training Wheels | |
| 18 | John Rathmell | Sweet Revenge Belgian Tripel | |
| 20-23 | Justin Scanlon | Lupe's Ginger Heaven | |
| Second Place | |||
| Group | Name | Beer Name | |
| 1, 6 | Bob Barrett | Dortmunder Blunder | |
| 2-5 | Richard Scott | Classic American Pilsner | |
| 7, 15 | Alex Pettit | Weizenhund | |
| 8, 11 | Brad Sancho | Ordinary Bitter | |
| 9, 19 | Kurt Klimkiewicz | Scottish Ale - Export 80 | |
| 10 | Derek Sheehan | Derek's Pale Ale | |
| 12, 13 | Spencer Weeks | Chocolate Dragon Stout | |
| 14 | Jeff Rankert | 2007 Double IPA | |
| 16, 17 | Chris Michalek | Wit | |
| 18 | Mike Mullins | Mike Daniel's Belgian Red | |
| 20-23 | Mike Scott | Lil Sprout Stout | |
| Third Place | |||
| Group | Name | Beer Name | |
| 1, 6 | Phil Kitkowski | Philler Lite | |
| 2-5 | Joe Walters | Walters Schwartzbier | |
| 7, 15 | David Curtis | California Common | |
| 8, 11 | Phil Kitkowski | Novi Nut Brown Ale | |
| 9, 19 | Richard Scott | Scottish Export | |
| 10 | Brad Sancho | Amber Ale | |
| 12, 13 | Eric Vermilion | Vermilion Robust Porter | |
| 14 | Bob Barrett | Amarillo IPA | |
| 16, 17 | Nick Ramsey | Goes Down Easy | |
| 18 | Kurt Klimkiewicz | Belgian Blonde Ale | |
| 20-23 | Justin Scanlon | Grateful Red | |